10 Places to Eat in Warwick, New York You Don’t Want to Miss

share this post:
Blog Post Peach

There is no shortage of great places to eat in Warwick, New York. From pubs to farm-to-table to gourmet Italian, the variety of cuisines and experiences available means you are sure to find something everyone can enjoy. 

We just can’t capture all of the delicious locations in a single blog post, so here are the top 10 places we recommend for your next visit to Warwick.

1. Landmark Inn

With a rich history that began with a homestead in the late 1700s that was converted into a restaurant in 1953, the Landmark Inn is a popular destination for anniversary celebrations. The menu features contemporary American cuisine made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. 

The Landmark Inn includes two dining rooms and a large parlor adjacent to the separate bar area that reflect the history of the building. Enjoy a delicious dinner in this unique space Tuesday-Sunday.


2. Yesterday’s Irish Pub

While visiting family in Warwick, New York, from Long Island, John Christison decided something was missing and set about establishing Yesterday’s Irish Pub, which has become a popular staple in the community for its tasty food and relaxed atmosphere. 

Yesterday’s offers a variety of draft beers and a large menu of Irish and American classics. Be sure to finish off your visit to Yesterday’s with one of the scrumptious, award-winning desserts made by Executive Pastry Chef Peggy Christison.  

If you are looking to accommodate a large number of people, Yesterday’s offers a banquet room with catering services on and off-site. 

3.Warwick Valley Winery and Distillery

There are a couple of options for dining and drinks at Warwick Valley Winery and Distillery. Choose between the Tasting Room & Cafe or Doc’s Outdoor Bar and Grille, both of which offer distinct menus based on the fresh ingredients grown on the farm.  

Take a tour of the Black Dirt Distillery and taste some of the best wines, ciders, and spirits while you enjoy live music every weekend. Warrick Valley Winery and Distillery hosts multiple music festivals throughout the year in a gorgeous natural amphitheater. 

Warwick Valley also offers apple picking with a variety of 65 different heirloom and modern apples to choose from. Apple picking season runs roughly from Labor Day through Halloween, depending on the weather. 

4. Bellvale Farms Creamery

If you want to try some of the best ice cream you’ve ever had, take a ride out to Bellvale Farms Creamery. The ice cream is made by hand every single day, along with yummy homemade waffle bowls. You can also have a delicious ice cream pie or cake. With over 50 different flavors on their rotating menu, you’ll want to come back many times to try them all. 

Bellvale Farms has been operating since 1819 with seven generations of family farmers and is recognized as one of the pillars of the Hudson Valley. The owners and employees are passionate about farming and providing quality dairy products to the surrounding areas. You can even learn more about each of the cows on the farm!

Bellvale Farms Creamery is open April-October, including many holidays with specific hours. Don’t forget to take a pint of your favorite flavor home with you!

If you’re staying at The Peach Grove House, this is only a short 4 minute drive away!

5. Clearview Vineyard

Savor some great wines while taking in some of the most breathtaking scenery in New York State at the beautiful Clearview Vineyard. Spend a delightful Saturday or Sunday afternoon on a tour of the winery and an accompanying wine tasting complete with seasonal food samplings.

Clearview Vineyard has been named one of the Top U.S. Vineyards by Travel + Leisure. Come see why for yourself and sip a glass of wine on the patio or take a bottle home with you.

6.Conscious Fork

Featuring a menu of delectable plant-based food, Conscious Fork is a vegan cafe dedicated to “nourishing the mind, body & soil℠.” Whether you are looking for a quick lunch or catering for an event, the Conscious Fork is an excellent choice for delicious and healthy food that is sourced and prepared responsibly. 

Conscious Fork is part of Conscious Habitat, whose mission is “to offer products and services that are good for people, the planet, our community and our animal friends.”  Along with the cafe and juice bar, there is also a spa, real estate services, and individual and business coaching available to help you improve your life in eco-friendly and sustainable ways.

7. Silvio’s Villa

No list of local eateries is complete without an option for delicious Italian food. Silvio’s Villa offers authentic Italian cuisine in the elegant ambiance of a gorgeously restored 18th-century mansion. 

Silvio’s Villa is the perfect location for a special event. With over 30 years of personalized event planning, our event planners can transform your ideas into a stunning and memorable occasion. The large dining room is perfect for any celebration, and private rooms and outdoor seating are also available to ensure your dining experience is as wonderful as can be. 

Based on 75 years of culinary tradition and a commitment to fresh, local, sustainable, non-GMO, hormone free, homemade ingredients, you don’t want to miss a chance to dine at Silvio’s Villa. 

8. Crystal Inn

The Crystal Inn is a unique steakhouse that serves classic and contemporary American cuisine made from locally- sourced ingredients, some of which are harvested earlier in the same day they are served to you in the restaurant. 

Because of its unique location in the heart of the Black Dirt region, the chefs at the Crystal Inn have access to the finest, freshest ingredients to create delicious, distinctive dishes that follow the seasons. 

There is no better place to experience the locavore movement of connecting “foodies” with the best local providers than the Crystal Inn. 

9. Eddie’s Road House

Eddie’s Road House has one of the most eclectic menu that combines influences from cuisines around the world. They offer specials that change each week, so you are sure to find something new and tasty each time you visit.

From ramen to tacos to burgers to pasta, Eddie’s Road House is the perfect place to enjoy a casual meal with craft beer. 

Eddie Cullari Sr. and Jr. are a legendary father-son duo who have created a community with their delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. Eddie’s Road House is open every day and a great stop for any trip to Warwick. 

10. The Grange

There are many restaurants that claim to be farm-to-table, but The Grange is a perfect example of what that popular phrase really means. The menu is completely designed around locally sourced products, including hand-crafted beers and wines. 

With a casual, but intimate atmosphere in a historic post office that has been repurposed, The Grange features the signature style of Jim Haurey, the chef and owner. 

The Grange is open Friday- Monday from 4-8 pm. Be sure to call ahead for a reservation to ensure a spot at the small and rustic farm-to-table dining experience.

Peach Grove House

Peach Grove House is the perfect destination for a memorable event, a stunning wedding, or a relaxing and romantic getaway. 

Located in Warwick, New York, just a few miles from JFK, EWR and Stewart airports – Peach Grove House is easily accessible while still providing a unique, historical experience you can’t get anywhere else. 

But don’t just take our word for it. Plan a visit today to see how wonderful Peach Grove House truly is.

peach grove house is the perfect destination

For a memorable event, a stunning wedding, or a relaxing and romantic getaway.

But don’t just take our word for it — plan a visit today to see how wonderful Peach Grove House truly is.


Your Stay

See rates and check
availability for your visit.


An Event

Reserve your special date and
explore our event options.